Is this supposed to happen or am I just unlucky?

So, I'm quite a new player, I am level 117 and just reached act 2 in destruction, I tried crafting an unique amulet twice now, and I found three unique amulets from drops, and every single time I get "Hangman". I mean, am I just being stupid, unlucky, or what?

Hangman amulets are the most common happens to a lot of ppl. Get used to farming fauzt and seeing only The Boulder jewels, ring of disengagement and hangmen drop

You will find a lot of shit amulets. And a lot of useless uniques also. This is Diablo. Do not worry about this.
Go gambling, gamble untill u will get rare[yellow] amulet.
Then go and buy oil of renewals, renew it untill u get what u want -)
I can say ~10% of amulets will have +3 all skills. mo what you want.
Do not forget to try oil of luck to get extra +1 all skills.

This rare amulets can be very-very good.

Hmmmm... Ok, Thanks guys! I'm happy because I didn't miss anything really obvious this time...

Well sometimes you might want to make a specific char and that Athulua's Oracle is the shit you want . But game says no .

Getting Emp bands once i got like 5-6 Idiot Ball rings in a row  

Well, hangman = free signet. xD
Get empy band with uniq cr8 recipe.